Major concerns have been raised about the safety of islanders in bad weather due to the loss of the entire telecommunications network during the power cuts of the past few days.
Following Isles MP Torcuil Crichton raising the issue in the House of Commons, a Harris doctor has spoken of the medical emergency that unfolded in Northton on Sunday (October 25) where a patient was unable to call him because all the phones were down.
The patient’s neighbours physically went to Leverburgh to find the doctor and, when he attended the patient and found he needed an ambulance to take him to hospital, he had to then drive a distance to get a mobile signal to summon the ambulance.
That situation was made more difficult because they had to wait several hours for an ambulance as the one unit based in Tarbert was on a priority emergency call elsewhere.
It has also emerged the Faire emergency response system was compromised because users can only raise an alert if there is an operational mobile network nearby and, at times, all the mobile phone networks were down at once.
Questioned about the situation, a Comhairle nan Eilean Siar spokesperson stated: "The sustained power outages across the Western Isles this weekend impacted the mobile network connection for many in our communities.
"While the Faire service was fully functional it relies on user network connection to deliver communications and allow action to be taken.
"Digital communication is vitally important, particularly considering its role in delivering emergency and support services.
"Comhairle nan Eilean Siar will request a review of the mobile network in the Western Isles, and the Comhairle notes the discussions on this matter in the House of Commons this week."
Crossroads Harris, which looks after the elderly and vulnerable living alone, was unable to check on its clients by phone because of the telecomms collapse and unable to check on them in person because the weather was so bad that travel was unsafe.
Although all the mobile networks were down at one point, the main issue is said to be the lack of working landline phones in power cuts. The old analogue landline system is being phased out and being replaced with digital systems which run off the internet.
As critics have long pointed out, the system has little resilience as the battery backup boxes for homer phones only provide power for around an hour and even the superior battery boxes only provide a few hours more.
Na h-Eileanan an Iar MP Torcuil Crichton raised the issue in the House of Commons this week.
As reported previously in welovestornoway – read more here – Mr Crichton highlighted how that the switchover from copper wire analogue systems to digital phone systems was leaving vulnerable people with no means of communications during blackouts.
He cited the case of the neighbours having to go to fetch the doctor in Harris. “The delay, when lives are at stake in bad weather, is unacceptable,” he said.
The GP involved, Dr Andrew Naylor, spoke with welovestornoway.com about the emergency and his concerns for patients.
The power had gone off in South Harris at around 4am on Sunday. Dr Naylor called for better backups and “a more robust” telecoms system, saying: “I’m no telephone expert but certainly it’s not 100 per cent dependable”.
He added: “Working in this sort of rural area is challenging at the best of times. We’ve got a high proportion of elderly patients in the practice. We’re sitting about 36 per cent which is way above the national average.”
The ambulance base is also 20 minutes to half an hour away, in Tarbert.
After 36 years in Harris, Dr Naylor is no stranger to the challenges of being a doctor in a rural community. However, he stressed: “We’re dependent on reasonable communications and last weekend was challenging.”
Residents who use the Crossroads and Faire support services were also left vulnerable when the mobile networks went down.
Faire users would not have been able to raise the alarm by pressing their red button because these signals need one working mobile phone network to be transmitted.
Morag Munro, secretary of Crossroads Harris, was covering for the manager over the weekend. She was concerned to realise she had no working phones to use to contact clients direct or to contact care attendants to get them to check on people.
“They’re all vulnerable. They’ve all got needs and some of them live alone and are elderly and I couldn’t contact them to check they were okay. And I couldn’t contact any of my care attendants to go and check on them, so it was quite a worry.
“There was absolutely no communication whatsoever available,” she said.
Initially, Mrs Munro had been comforted to think that at least the Faire alarm system was in place – but was dismayed to learn, later, that it was also not an option. She said: “I was worried. I was praying they would be okay because that was the only option open to me.” The prevailing conditions were far too adverse for her to set out in her own car.
Mrs Munro said it was time for the community to make its own plans. She jokingly harked back to the old days of raising an alert, telling how the Isle of Taransay would light a fire somewhere and send up smoke to signal to the mainland they needed help.
However, Mrs Munro stressed the seriousness of the present challenge. “I think the Faire situation needs to be sorted out and we all need to put plans in place. I’ve come to the conclusion that almost every house will need its own plan.”
Crossroads, she said, will review their own emergency plan. “We’ve got our own contingency plan but we weren’t prepared for this kind of complete blackout. We were using systems which, turns out, we can’t rely on so we’re going to have our own plan – and it’s going to be physical because we’re not able to depend on technology. It’s going to mean that we’ll designate people to go and check on people.”
